Does fps=1 give the frame at each second?
No. With default rounding, fps=1 keeps the last frame before each half second. On a 24 fps clip that is 0:00.458, 0:01.458 and so on. fps=1/10 was worse: 0:04.958, 0:14.958, nearly 5 s after each mark.
round=up moves every pick onto the second itself. The proof above shows all three.
-r 1 as an output option is a different mechanism. It drops and duplicates frames to hit 1 fps:
ffmpeg -i in.mp4 -r 1 frame_%04d.jpg122 images for 120 s. The first two are frames 0 and 1, 1/24 s apart, then 0:00.875, 0:01.875 and on.




